The desk · UK Written by the AI desk
Calls grow for change to rape law after Joanne Young case
The daughter of a woman drugged and raped by her husband over 13 years has joined calls for the government to close a loophole that allows "third-party consent" to be raised as a defence in rape trials.
The daughter of Joanne Young, who was drugged, raped and advertised for sex online by her husband, is among those calling for a change in the way such cases are defended in court, according to the BBC [1].
Philip Young drugged and abused his wife over a 13-year period, using websites and apps to invite men to their home in Swindon without her knowledge, the BBC reported [1]. On Thursday, four men were found guilty of sexual offences against her.
Young's daughter, Alex Young, said: "It has been 23 years since this was last updated. Society has progressed, crime has progressed. So why hasn't the law progressed with it?" according to the BBC [1].
Philip Young advertised his wife for sex using websites including Craigslist, Grindr and FabSwingers without her knowledge, the BBC said [1]. During the trial, prosecutors said the four men, who were strangers to each other, failed to seek consent from Joanne Young before engaging in sexual activity with her. The defendants claimed they had been duped by Philip Young and believed she was consenting, according to the BBC [1].
The Sexual Offences Act 2003 states that "a person consents if he agrees by choice, and has the freedom and capacity to make that choice", the BBC noted [1], adding that there is no defined law stating third-party consent is a valid defence.
In a post on LinkedIn, Alex Young wrote: "We live in a world where there is debate over whether third-party consent is enough to have sex with someone... and that is enough to use it as an argument in a court of law," according to the BBC [1].
Her comments echoed those of her mother, who spoke on the steps of Winchester Crown Court after the trial. "No-one should be able to give it [consent] on your behalf," Joanne Young said, according to the BBC [1]. She has waived her right to anonymity. "I urge the government to look at this as a priority so that women are properly protected in future," she said.
Kate Parker, a criminal barrister and founder of the Schools Consent Project, told the BBC that legally, a third party or partner cannot consent on a person's behalf [1]. "The law makes that very clear. A person consents if he or she agrees by choice and has the freedom and capacity to make that choice," she said, adding that in a case where someone has been made unconscious, "there is no possible way that that person is able to consent because of course they have no capacity." Parker said the defence used by the four men "doesn't make sense legally, and that's not a legal position that can be supported in court", though she said defence lawyers might still raise a genuine belief in consent as mitigation for sentencing, according to the BBC [1].
Also quoted by the BBC was Laura Bishop, from Bristol, who has waived her anonymity after her ex-husband was sentenced to 14 years in prison for drugging and raping her while inviting other men to abuse her [1]. "It's something that unfortunately you can never get over," Bishop told BBC Radio 4's Today programme. Bishop, who holds a PhD in cyber crime, said the websites used to advertise her "are still active and are known by the police to not provide evidence and forensics when asked", according to the BBC [1].
Debbie Beadle, chief executive of Wiltshire-based domestic abuse charity Fear Free, told the BBC that "six in seven rapes against women are done by someone they know and this adds a barrier to people coming forward," adding that Joanne Young's decision to speak out "will help others when this has happened to them" [1].
The government has not yet responded publicly to the calls for a change in the law, which remains unconfirmed by the BBC at this stage [1].




